Quantcast

qPCR: Plexor and SYBR compared

In my last article I introduced you to the Plexor System. And from that we already know that while in reactions that user SYBR Green for detection, fluorescence increases with accumulation of PCR product, with Plexor the fluoresence decreases. Today I want to compare some other well-known features of SYBR Green chemistry and see how it compares against Plexor.

First, a quick recap of how a PCR reaction tracked by SYBR and PlexorTM chemistries would look in an amplification plot:

qpcr

Now let’s see how they compare in other areas:

Signal Specificity

SYBR Green I is a DNA intercalator dye, whereas in Plexor, the fluorescent label is incorporated as part of the primer and the quencher is present in the dNTP mix.

Since SYBR Green binds to any double stranded DNA, non-specific signal could be obtained if, for example, there is significant accumulation of  primer dimers or non-specific products.

In Plexor on the other hand the signal obtained is a direct result of the interaction between the fluor on the primer with the quencher on the nucleotide incorporated into the amplicon, and is therefore specific to the amplifed product. The Plexor reagent mix also contains a proprietary primer-dimer inhibitor that allows greater signal specificity than SYBR chemistry (3).

PCR inhibition

It is known that concentrations of SYBR dye required to saturate PCR products can result in PCR inhibition, therefore only limited concentrations of the dye can be used. But since the fluorescent signal on Plexor is integral to the reaction components themselves, problems with PCR inhibition are not an issue.

As a side note, use of an internal amplification control (IAC) is a good idea when sample is known to contain contaminants that inhibit PCR reaction. A typical IAC would be a non-target DNA sequence that is present in the same sample reaction tube, which is co-amplified simultaneously with the target sequence (2).

Melt curve analysis

During melt curve analysis SYBR Green I dye can migrate to other double-stranded regions resulting in incorrect analysis. This can be a particular problem, for example, when melt curves are used to distinguish between genotypes (1).

But dye migration is not an issue with Plexor and quenching of fluorescent signal is reversible, so melt curve analysis is not a problem. The use of labeled primers for melt curve analysis solves many of the problems associated with SYBR Green dye (1).

Multiplexing

SYBR Green is a single channel signal, so is not amenable to multiplexing.

But in Plexor the iso-dC on the primer is labeled at the 5′ with a fluor and by using a different fluor on each set of primers, it is possible to probe multiple targets in the same reaction. Depending on the instrument and choice of oligo vendor, Promega makes specific recommendations for dyes that can be used. The dye selector tool is also freely available: http://www.promega.com/applications/pcr/qpcr/dye_selector.htm

The downside of Plexor

Believe it or not, there are some disadvantages unique to Plexorâ„?.

1. Iso-dG is part of the dNTP mix. It has to be purchased from Promega and cannot be used as part of any non-Plexor PCR reaction.

2. As with any fluorescence technology, the reagents have to be protected from light. Since fluorescence labels are known to degrade with time, the cost of reagents can be expensive depending on throughput.

3. The absorption maximum of Dabcyl occurs at 474nm which falls below the emission wavelength of commonly used fluorophores such as FAM, TET and JOE. This means that quenching efficiency of Dabcyl is not 100%. It is therefore important to exercise good care in choosing the right fluorophore (4).

Can you think of other features? Drop us a line to let us know.

References:

  1. Cart T. Wittwer et al. 2003. Clinical Chemistry 49 (3). P. 396-406
  2. Patrick Fach et al. 2003. Journal of Clincial Microbiology. 41(12). P. 5835
  3. Douglas R. Storts et al.
  4. Black Hole Quencher Dye.

7 Comments

  1. Marc on August 31, 2009 at 4:14 am

    Hi Shoba!

    Thanks for your quick reply!
    I think I might try the Plexor system if I have time… where do you buy your oligos from? And the Plexor mastermix is only available from Promega I suppose?

    Cheers,
    Marc

    • Shoba on August 31, 2009 at 4:45 am

      Hi Marc,
      I am glad to know you are thinking of trying it. For primers, IDT is my favorite. But, Promega website also lists Biosearch Technologies. Scroll down to the bottom of this page linked here for that informaton. And, yes, the mastermix has to be purchased from Promega. I would be interested to know how it goes.
      Regards,
      Shoba

  2. Marc on August 25, 2009 at 1:40 am

    Sounds like a pretty cool technique…!
    But, why is nobody using it? I mean, everybody I know uses SBYR Green on probes.

    Also, the multiplexing capability sounds pretty nice. Have you tried that yourself? I suppose you first have to optimize the single reactions using non-labelled primers and then hope for the best?

    Thanks for writing this article!
    Marc

    • Shoba on August 25, 2009 at 12:50 pm

      Hi Marc,
      Great Question! I don’t know why it is not so popular. I keep asking myself the same question all the time. All I can think of is that SYBR has a big cost advantage over Plexor and Taqman entered the market much sooner than Plexor.

      I have used Plexor and still use it. For multiplex reactions in general, it is good to optimize individual primers in monoplex reactions first before proceeding to multiplex. Depending on target abundance, the primer or reagent concentrations or both are adjusted to obtain the same Ct as in the intial monoplex reaction.

      Optimization for primers pairs with SYBR is not required since the system uses only two primers just like SYBR. But if you are concerned that the cost of the fluor labels and special dNTP mix can be high, then yes, SYBR can be used for intial studies. I hope this helps.

      Regards,

      Shoba

Leave a Comment





This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share via
Copy link