New Channels on Bitesize Bio

To help you find information on exactly what you need we're implementing channels, a new way to browse content

Each channel is focused on a specific technique or area and authored/presented by hand-picked authors who are experts in their field. Make sure you don't miss a thing by checking the box below for each channel that interests you.

In return we'll send you one email per month that brings you the latest from your chosen channel(s), along with free members-only content.

Check out our upcoming new channels; Flow Cytometry and Cell Culture, we'll be launching them very soon!

I would like to receive the newsletters for the following channels

Cell Culture
Flow Cytomery
Microscopy & Imaging
Next Generation Sequencing
Writing, Publishing and Presenting
Cloning & Expression


My email address is:

Birth of the Cell Doctrine

by in Books
From the Bitesize Bio channel

Medium ImageAs a general rule of thumb, it is recommended to be familiar with the history of one’s scientific field, and not merely the contemporary trends of thought.

That’s generally why I liked The Birth of the Cell so much when I read it. Dissatisfied by the standard accounts of the origin of the cell doctrine, Henry Harris read the original writings of the relevant early cytologists from the first visualization of animalcules to the identification of the cell nucleus and binary fission. Although very dense reading, the result is a book that describes the slow, awkward development of a science and the rivalries of the scholars involved.

For instance, Matthias Schleiden, Theodor Schwann, and Rudolf Virchow turn out to not be the singularly brilliant thinkers ahead of their time that we think, when we hear their names at the top of the cell doctrine. Other names have largely been forgotten when it comes to the cell doctrine. Jan Evangelista Purkyne is such an example, whose reputation far from adequately honors his work, for reasons quite other than scientific. From Page 91:

The number of eponyms that still bear his name is evidence enough of his productivity, including Purkyne’s vesicle (the vesicula germinativa), Purkyne’s cells (the large cells that he discovered in the cerebellum), Purkyne’s corpuscles (the lacunae of bone), Purkyne’s granular layer (branched spaces in the enamel of teeth), Purkyne’s figures (dark lines produced by the retinal vessels under certain conditions of illumination), Purkyne’s images (three pairs of images seen in the pupil).

Purkyne also made significant and early correlations between plant and animal tissues, before those of Schwann (who largely avoided citing Purkyne). As a consequence, it is the 1837-38 work of Schleiden, Schwann, and the mentor Johannes M??ller, presented in widely circulated monographs, that are remembered.

Similarly, the work of Robert Remak, also an outsider in German society, was largely stolen by Rudolf Virchow, who was a better lecturer than scientist. Virchow himself conceded that he could was not the discoverer of the ideas which he was putting forward, but he did gladly take credit as the propagator of those ideas, for which he gained fame. From Page 135:

One of the factors that contributed to the durable success of Vichow’s book [Cellularpathologie] was his use of the phrase ‘Omnis cellula e cellular’… it is not uncommon, even nowadays, for a theory or a substance to become fashionable if it is given an attractive name of sobriquet. But it would be a mistake to regard Cellularpathologie merely as a piece of didacticism, for in it Virchow assembled a very wide range of disparate observations, some of which were his own, and imposed on them a unity that flowed from his central theme, namely, that in all organisms, plant as well as animal, the formation of tissues was driven by the binary fission of cells.”

Harris gleaned all of these observations from reading the journal articles, monographs, and textbooks of the period, to see what the scientists actually thought at the time, and how those minds changed over time.

Articles in your inbox

Enter your email to be informed when we publish more articles like this on BsB, and also get access to all of these goodies:

  • Free ebooks and audiobooks on the topics that matter to you
  • Access to Member’s-only articles and Videos
  • Advance notice of new webinars and eBooks
  • Access to make comments and ask questions on BsB



What to read next

Notes of a Biology Watcher

Part science, part prose, Lewis Thomas’ books Lives of a Cell and The Medusa and the Snail are creative, thought-provoking, and entertaining.

Book Review: ‘The Selfish Gene’, by Richard Dawkins

A few popular science books rise above the genre and become pop-stars of the book world – bestsellers. Even fewer among them change public discourse and, finally, culture. The Selfish Gene (TSG) by Richard Dawkins is one of these rare books. Published in 1976, TSG is not only still in print, but according to the [...]

Genome Structure and Modularity

A minireview recently in Genomics caught my eye with the title Coexpression, coregulation, and cofunctionality of neighboring genes in eukaryotic genomes that sounded just like a passage that I recalled from Richard Dawkins’ The Selfish Gene: …the ‘environment’ of a gene consists largely of other genes, each of which is itself being selected for its [...]

Book Review: On Growth and Form

Unlike most naturalists and biologists before and since, who were only satisfied if they could understand a particular form by the configuration of its immediate precedents, D’Arcy Thompson was quite satisfied with a mathematical description or a physical analogy. He truly viewed the variety of biological forms that he looked at with the eyes of [...]

About the author

What do you think?

One comment

  1. from apalazzo on

    I’ll have to add this book to the list. Thanks for that.

Subscribe to Channels

To receive information about any of our new channels click on the button below.
subscribe to the channel newsletter »

Write for us

Have a short tip, a written
article or a video you'd like
to see published?
write for us »